AI Reshapes Broker Client Ties

New research shows AI is now a measurable factor in how employers select insurance brokers, according to a 2026 survey of more than 1,400 U.S. employers.

AI moves from background trend to selection criterion

The Zywave 2026 Broker Services Survey, an annual study of employer expectations, found that “failure to leverage modern technology and AI‑powered tools” entered the list of top reasons an employer might change brokers.

The report notes that integrating AI into benefits administration and HR operations rose to the top‑10 list of employee‑benefits challenges for the first time.

Martin Simoncic, chief executive officer at Zywave, said the data “tells a clear story: AI is no longer optional infrastructure for brokers, it’s becoming a visible part of how clients judge value.”

He added that employers want brokers who use AI to work faster and more accurately while still acting as strategic partners.

Slow response times, inconsistent communication and a broker’s inability to act as a strategic advisor remain the leading reasons employers consider switching brokers.

Related: Fintech firms rely on aging tech systems

However, 2026 marks the first year that a broker’s lack of modern technology appears among the top eight factors overall, indicating that digital competence is now seen as a baseline expectation rather than a differentiator for larger firms.

Trusted advisor role continues to rise

The survey shows the “trusted advisor” expectation climbing from 56% of respondents in 2023 to 71% in 2026.

Employers increasingly want technology that removes friction from day‑to‑day service, paired with human advice that can translate data into strategy.

Self‑service portals are quietly reshaping the relationship.

Desired weekly contact with a broker fell from 41.9% in 2025 to 33.4% in 2026, suggesting that clients are relying more on digital tools for routine tasks.

Employers are asking brokers to help sort signal from noise as AI tools become part of daily HR operations.

The gap between what employers need and what brokers currently deliver creates an opening for firms that can combine AI‑enabled efficiency with higher‑order strategic services.

Related: Alipay expands with new bank partners

For many companies, the practical impact of this shift means faster benefits enrollment and more accurate cost projections, which can free HR staff to focus on employee engagement rather than administrative minutiae.

AI joins emerging commercial risk conversation

“Addressing coverage needs for emerging risks” entered the top‑10 commercial insurance challenges for the first time, with AI listed alongside geopolitical instability, supply‑chain disruption and climate‑related events.

Rising premiums remain the top overall commercial concern, cited by 70% of respondents, but AI‑driven exposure now appears as a distinct risk factor.

In practice, businesses that rely on brokers adept at spotting AI‑related blind spots may avoid costly surprises, such as unexpected liability from algorithmic decisions or data‑privacy breaches that fall outside traditional coverage.

The survey’s findings will be discussed in a webinar on August 5, hosted by Zywave.

Interested parties can register through the company’s website.